The Law Office of Anne F. Borghetti, State and Federal Criminal Defense Lawyer

  Federal Criminal Lawyer Anne F. Borghetti  

Blood Test Thrown Out by Supreme Court


After speeding and crossing the center line, Missouri police stopped Tyler McNeely. After declining a breath test he was arrested and transported to a hospital where he refused to a blood test. The officer instructed a lab tech to take the sample. After the BAC tested above the legal limit, McNeely was charged with Driving While Intoxicated (DWI).

McNeely’s representation moved to suppress arguing the officer never attempted to secure a warrant. The State Supreme Court affirmed. This week the Supreme Court affirmed in a 5-4 decision in favor of McNeely. The opinion by Justice Sotomayor opined on Parts I, II-A, II-B, and IV. It is important to note that none of the Court’s four opinions state that that in every case must police officers obtain a warrant. This creates a case-by-case review and suggests that a warrant is prudent. This also makes it more important than ever that anyone under investigation for impaired driving consult immediately with legal council.

If you are in need of legal consultation, contact us immediately at (727) 502-0300 for a free 30 minute consultation.

Affiliated websites

© 2014 Anne F. Borghetti, PA

Facebook-The-Law-Office-of-Anne-F-Borghetti Twitter-The-Law-Office-of-Anne-F-Borghetti

St Petersburg Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer Anne Borghetti

Phone: 727.502.0300

12211 49th St N, Suite 1
Clearwater, FL 33762

13055 W Linebaugh Ave
Tampa, FL 33626
(By Appointment Only)

Llámenos en Español

Latest Blog Entries

Feds Pursuing Greatest Penalties, Including Capital, for Drug Cases (2018-03-23)

A 2018 guidance memo regarding drug cases states that “federal prosecutors must consider every lawful tool at their disposal.” 

Tell ICE Agents to Stop Making Arrests at Courthouses (2018-03-01)

New legislation has been introduced - the Protecting Sensitive Locations Act (H.R. 1815 and S. 845) – to limit ICE from making arrests at or near many sensitive locations. 

Home Invasion Call Results in Drug Charges (2013-08-07)

A call regarding a home invasion in the Hill ‘n Dale subdivision of Brooksville resulted in drug charges against three.

Supreme Court Rules Against Florida Environmental Officials (2013-08-06)

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled governments must show how money or easements for land development permits are related to the damages that they might cause.

Five Arrested in Florida Workers’ Comp Fraud (2013-08-05)

The Department of Financial Services Division of Insurance Fraud alleges the owner of a staffing agency misled consumers into believing that his company was licensed and could perform workers’ comp services for client companies.

Knowing your rights at a DUI checkpoint (2013-07-15)

A 21-year-old Tennessee man released a video on YouTube that has gone viral (and has since been made private) showing him trying to navigate a DUI checkpoint.